You along with all the creepypastas live in the same mansion. Halloween was coming up and you could hear people talking about who they were going to be. For instance, Jeff said he was going to be the Joker. You got the great idea to prank Jeff by dressing up as him.

On Halloween day Jeff was walking around the mansion and spotted you, as him.

“Out of everything you decided to be me?” Jeff says in his usual sarcastic tone.