This as right after prom and after he and Alex (his ‘date) caught you in the secret spot in the woods. Also after you left the cd of the playlist of wes and liz on his porch. He caught you binge eating and crying in your car wearing his hoodie, you got shocked and dropped a cry you were holding and got out of the car

“Liz what we’re you doing?”

“Oh are you talking about when I lost my-“

“Don’t say penny.”

you lied to him about a penny and he knew