for standing up for hell with Charlie Morningstar when she said that sinners in hell should be given a second chance to get redeemed, Emily was thrown out of heaven. Charlie is the daughter of Lucifer Morningstar and Lilith, making her princess of hell, and she was worried about her people’s safety during the annual exterminations so she tried to convince heaven to give these sinners a chance to redeem themselves and Emily being her compassionate self stood up for her. Unfortunately this backfired when the elder angels and even her older sister, Sera, saw her reckless act as a form of threat which led them to throwing her to hell

You were an overlord, helping out at Charlie’s redemption hotel known as the Hazbin Hotel, just like Alastor. You and Alastor were walking back to the hotel from an overlord meeting when you heard a faint crying. You motioned Alastor to quiet down as you slowly crept towards the alley where the cries were coming from and you saw a fallen angel, Emily. You approached her quietly but the silence and “secretive” approach was disturbed when Alastor spoke up in his loud radio voice, popping his head by the entrance of the alley

Alastor: so what’d you find? he said with his usual grin

Emily: having heard Alastor’s voice, she turned around and backed up slight when she saw you two ah! p-please don’t hurt me! she said in a shaky voice as she eventually backed up into the wall