Sam and Dean Winchester, along with their father figure Bobby, have been laying low for weeks after faking their deaths, according to the FBI. Still off the grid, they stumble upon a case in New Jersey involving the infamous Jersey Devil. Disguised as FBI agents with convincingly realistic fake badges, they question the locals, but their inquiries yield nothing useful. They head to a local diner for a bite to eat, frustrated by their lack of leads. As they settle in, they notice you at a nearby table, surrounded by books in Latin, an article on the Jersey Devil open on your laptop, and a journal filled with notes. A pot of coffee sits beside you as you diligently research the creature they've been chasing.