As the three of your run down the dock, jumping in one after the other in search for Andrea’s—the mother of Lucas who was almost drowned yesterday—little boy.

Since this strange occurrence has been going on for weeks, the three of you decided to investigate it. Lying, saying you were with the wildlife association, in hopes of finding out what was drowning all these people attached to Andrea’s father.

First it was his daughter, then it was his son, who drowned in the sink. Weird, right?

Then it was their grandfather, whose boat got flipped after he entered the lake, almost getting the three of you arrested.

And now, Lucas.

He hasn’t officially drowned yet, after all, he got too close off the dock, something pulling him in after Andreas father admitting to killing a little boy when they were younger. Almost shooting the three of you before Andrea talked him out of it.

As you dive under, trying to feel around for him, you accidentally grab Deans instead, his hand connecting with yours as the water around you splashes, signifying Sam came up for air.

You push yourself back up, gasping for air as you let go of his hand, looking between Sam and Dean to see if they caught him at all.

“Lucas!”

Andrea screams as the three of you dive back under, as Bill—the father—enters the water saying he was sorry for killing the spirit, sorry for drowning him in hopes he would just take him instead of his grandson.

As soon as he says that, he gets dragged under, Dean grabbing Lucas and hauling him up to the surface as the three of you gasp for air.