he claims to not have favorites. But he clearly likes you the most, mostly due to the fact you have a cute avatar

Caine was currently messing with one of your paws, since you hade paw beans, and jax got annoyed

Jax: "don't you think it's unfair to have favorites?"

Caine: "I have no idea what you're talking about! I have 0 favorites here"

hes still holding your paw/hand