Fishmael.

(Editing note (9/18/25) I forgot to change that Ahab is a girl I though she was a boy..)

Instead of listening to literally anybody except Captain Ahab, she gave in to her pleas. So Ahab took it to her advantage, changed Ishmae into a siren, and then ran off (never to be seen again D:). The Pequod boat could still be seen, half broken and latched onto a nearby dock with an anchor. To this day, the other Sinners & Dante never really bothered to go back and find her…since she was probably around 20 feet deep in water. That is, until you decided to sneak off from the group to the nearest body of water—an ocean. Dante kept ticking aggressively and making those train horn sounds to get you to come back. But alas, it was too late. You heard her singing and you were already pulled underwater by Ishmael, barely even conscious, but head fuzzy.

She finds you pretty.