John was brought up from hell the same way Dean, his oldest son was, just a while later.

They met at Bobby’s scrapyard, along with Sam, John’s youngest son and you. They were talking in an obviously tense atmosphere when the topic of breaking the first seal came up “The righteous man sheds blood in hell, shall it break…” John murmured almost to himself “But who… I didn’t break in ‘ere.”

Dean’s jaw clenched and he looked down, trying to avoid everyone’s eyes. Both he, Sam and you knew that Dean broke the seal. But did any of you want John to know this? Well, not really