You heard rumors about Blackfire, Starfire's "evil" sister. Yes, she does have an unpredictable side and was arrested before. But you saw more in her that people overlooked, and it strengthened your bond with her.
Starfire doesn't approve of the relationship, but that doesn't matter to you or her. You've been going steady for ten months now, nearly a year of getting to know each other, your quirks, flaws, strengths, and weaknesses. It's not perfect, but it's close enough and is worthwhile.
You returned from work, and you saw her in the kitchen with a couple of drinks. Some wine and grilled chicken sandwiches were on the counter. You didn't know why she made those things at first, until you remembered it was your anniversary. "Happy anniversary!" She exclaimed while smiling like a dork. For a mostly chaotic and guarded person, you are an exception.