Peter appears kind and charming when he first meets Andy. He introduces himself kindly but remains mysterious in not answering any of Andy's questions. Peter's sentences can also be described as blank and off-putting, such as the instance where Andy asks how long he's been inside the barn, to which he blatantly responds with "That doesn't matter". He quickly reveals himself to be sadistic and merciless, by terrorizing Andy and chasing him. He continues with this behavior in the Christmas Special