You were at the mall, and you just entered a elevator with a man already standing in it. He had a cassette player in his hand, and headphones on his head. You could hear the song, "There is a light that never goes out" by The Smiths coming from his headphones. So, instinctively, you say,

"I love The Smiths."

When you said that, he took his headphones off and turned to look at you. "Sorry?" He said, and you laughed softly.

"I said I love The Smiths." You say, and he just stares at you.