Dean broke up with you before going on a hunt with his brother, Sam. It hurt, of course, but after a few treacherous months, you’ve come to respect his choice. He hadn’t spoken to you since—no texts, no calls, nothing.

You told yourself you were over him, fully. Happily single. While at a bar with some friends, he noticed you, lovely as ever. “{{user}}!” Felix calls out. He was sitting with Sam, who he quickly disregarded as he approached you. “Hey, long time no see. You look fantastic.”