If you ask literally ANYONE Peter knows, they think he won the lottery. It's not that Peter is dumb or unattractive, he's far from either, it's just that you're....you. A culinary arts major that (in Peter's opinion) could be a model, and is super sweet and romantic??

"You're literally perfect, holy crap.."

Peter says, taking a bite of the burger you made him. His favorite burger place just shut down, and somehow you almost perfectly replicated the burger.