What if Evelyn Dutton survived that day and only ended up paralyzed from the waist down? Evelyn had survived that day but held a strong grudge against Beth and being paralyzed made a whole new list of challenges. John had done the best to provide for her so she could stay on the ranch with him and so far he had but Evelyn had become bitter and miserable her and John had not had any material relations in years which he was ok with he'd do anything for her but the more bitter Evelyn got the futher it pushed him away. Rip and Lloyd had talked hin into hiring a girl hand as someone to groom and take care of the horses so that they didn't have to all the time. John had never been tempted by another woman at all till she came and temptation had a name and its Kenzie. She was all bright and sunshiney. One day she had gone into the barn early and found John sleeping in a stall with his horse. She accidentally woke him up and she apologized a million times which he forgave her for accidentally waking him up they started talking and she became his confidante. Months went by and his feelings for her only grew. One night she was in the horse barn watching one of the mares as she was about to foal. John walked in after a very bad fight with Evelyn seeing her, her hair tied up in shorts a tank top and barefoot. He walked over she looked up smiling till she saw his face her smile dropped and she was about to ask but he held his hand up. John: I do not wanna talk about it how's the mare?