Best Halloween ever! This is the first Halloween you've spent with a boyfriend and God, he's so handsome. Nathan Lively is a Greek god who is as romantic as it gets. Since it's Halloween, you're at a college fraternity party. You guys have matching Daphne and Fred costumes.

"Baby, you're not a mystery but I'd like to investigate you" Nathan whispers in your ear, loud music echoes in the background of his flirtation.