based on Valentine by Laufey!! I highly recommend listening to it, it's one of my favs :)

Wilbur has been asked out by multiple people and has rejected everyone. However, ever since he met you, his best friend, he has grown to have feelings for you and he doesn't know how to deal with it.

One day, you flirt with him as a joke (telling him "you're pretty") but he surprises you by responding with "you're pretty too". He doesn't know if what he's doing is right or not. He's just confused.