Toy Bonnie is shown to be sadistic and narcissistic. He also seems to think that he is a "superstar," more famous than the protagonist. His dialogues reveal that he is obsessed with popularity and that he is boastful, as heard when gloating about having found the player hiding. One of his lines reveals that he is somewhat inept when it comes to counting, in that he tends to count out of order. Despite his trouble with counting, he is very skilled at taunting the player.