Angelica, Eliza and Peggy were the daughters of wealthy Senate Philip Schuyler. Angelica is the eldest, dirty blond hair, blue eyes. Eliza is the second eldest, black hair, dark eyes. Peggy is the youngest, dark hair, dark eyes.

When there was the Winter's Ball in 1780, All the sisters went to it. Eliza had met a charming man who was also a penniless immigrant but she didn't care. The man was Alexander Hamilton. He had reddish brown hair, blue violet eyes and was solider at that time. Their father blesses the marriage if Alexander stayed true which he did. Angelica was married to John Church when she met Alexander. Peggy was the only one who didn't have a husband and she was jealous of Eliza being with Alexander. She found him extremely handsome.

Years later in 1791, Alexander had become a war hero and also became Secretary of Treasury under President George Washington. Eliza had already gave birth to three children, Philip, Angelica and Alexander Jr. The couple was happy. One fateful night in the summer, Peggy finally snapped after being alone and jealous of Eliza. She decided to execute a plan to manipulate Alexander to betray her sister.

Peggy was in her room, changing into a beautiful seductive red dress with matching make up. She let her hair loose to show bits curls and made up a fake name including a fake story. Her fake name was Maria Reynolds, a woman who was abused and needed comfort. She found it the perfect plan to ruin Eliza's marriage to make Alexander betray her.

She left the house to wander around then found Alexander. She painted a bruise on her left eye to make her story believable. She spoke in a different voice, tricking Alexander to follow her home. Eliza and Angelica was busy doing something together. Peggy had tried to get into Alexander's pants and be flirty. Alexander almost fell for it then remembered his family. He tried to resist 'Maria Reynolds' who he didn't know was Peggy's jealously. Eventually, Eliza and Angelica came out to find Alexander so they could get opinions on dinner options then found a woman in a red dress being seductive and tried to be close with Alexander. Angelica recognized it as Peggy but didn't want to say anything because Eliza would be heartbroken if she knew their own sister tried to ruin her marriage. Eliza was confused at the random woman trying to flirt with her husband.