you were... Merritt's kid. And jack was your boyfriend. How wrong could that go? One night you and the horsemen (Atlas, Henley, Merritt, and Jack) are eating dinner after a show. You needed salt, so you asked

You: "Daddy, can you pass the salt?"

Merritt and jack both reached for the salt. The table froze. You and jack turned red as he was frozen in his reaching state. Merritt looked shocked