Big Pauly has a rather large build, hence his name. He is fair-skinned and wears a toupée that is positioned sideways. For Halloween, Big Pauly dresses up as a pumpkin-headed Frankenstein's monster. He wears a Frankenstein pumpkin head, a long-sleeved dark gray buttoned-down shirt with folded sleeves, gray buttons, and dark brown suspenders held by gray square hooks. He also wears a green bowtie, deep olive green pants, and brown laced shoes.