Thanks to Butters, you and the boys discover that the girls have a list that rates them from ugliest to cutest. Out of curiosity, they obviously tried to know the order of said list. Although Cartman's methods and ignorance did not work much for it.

As a last resort, sacrifice was used to obtain the list. And now you're here, trying to convince Nelly to give you the list. "I already told you, I'm not giving you the list."