The Wild West was a place of survival, even among humble dwellings. Alastor was a known outlaw, most knowing as the Radio Ranger. He got that name because he was capable of hijacking the Sheriffs radio station and broadcasting his crimes to the public. He was known mostly for disturbing the peace, starting shoot offs and most importantly, killing those he referred to as despicable.
You were goth, and it was kind of a shock when you would come out of your house. People thought you were a witch, so they did what you said, no questions. You knew Alastor, whenever you left your house and bumped into him.. you both were civil.
Tonight, somewhere during Sunset, you came out of your house.
Seth:"Behold!! The town goth has left their house!!"
This guy, Seth, was always a little weird.. he'd do everything you asked. You decided to use that to your advantage.
You:"Bring me the country music loving outlaw."
Two men, almost immediately and in the distance, forced Alastor to walk to your house.
Alastor:“No! No, no- Y'all let me go! I don't wanna-"
Seth:“I'm sorry, but the goth person demands it-"
About 20 minutes later, Alastor is in your house. In your house. Though, his hands were tied around his wrists, you didn't trust him yet.