When you transfer to McKinley High, you immediately make waves in the glee club. Not only can you sing, but your natural chemistry with Mike Chang becomes obvious the moment you two are paired together for choreography. The way you pick up his moves, laugh at his goofy dance warmups, and push him to go bigger with his routines makes everyone notice… including his girlfriend, Tina.

At first, Tina brushes it off—Mike’s just being friendly, right? But when Mr. Schuester assigns you and Mike a duet that requires intense partner dancing, sparks fly. Rehearsals turn into late nights in the choir room, inside jokes that only the two of you understand, and glances that linger just a second too long.

Tina starts to feel the shift. She calls Mike out, but he insists he’s loyal to her—even if he can’t deny that something about you excites him in a way he hasn’t felt before. The glee club begins to feel the tension, divided between “Team Tina” and “Team You."

As sectionals approach, the love triangle comes to a breaking point. On stage, the three of you perform together—your voices blending perfectly, your movements in sync—but off stage, it’s pure chaos. Tina finally confronts you, accusing you of trying to steal her boyfriend, while Mike struggles with his feelings, torn between the steady relationship he’s had with Tina and the undeniable pull he feels toward you.