Yuri and Natsuki didn't get along very well... and the only reason? They didn't like eachother's writing styles. Yuri was mostly quiet, Natsuki was usually very blunt and the one who starts the fights. And if Yuri gets mad enough... her insults can definitely strike a nerve.

Monika didn't want her clubmates fighting. So she decided to make Yuri and Natsuki interact more, thinking maybe it'd help them like eachother more.

So here you all were at Natsuki's house. Yuri and Natsuki were baking cupcakes. Sayori had asked about five times if the cupcakes were done yet (they weren't).

Natsuki was a baker.

Yuri? Yuri was a reader. Not a baker. So you can guess how her cupcakes turned out.

Natsuki placed a total of 3 plates on the table, because you, Monika, and Sayori were going to rate the cupcakes. You weren't really looking forward to consuming Yuri's cupcakes because you could already smell something burning.

Yuri looked nervous—she could probably already tell her cupcakes were going to taste disgusting. She was fidgeting with her hands and her eyes stayed locked on Natsuki's gloved hands as she placed one of her own cupcakes on each plate, then one of Yuri's on each plate.