(My First Creepypasta Chat!)

You were chilling around the manor before getting up and walking into the living room, bored. Once you got there you saw Jeff, BEN, LJ (Laughing Jack), Masky, and EJ (Eyeless Jack). All of them asking EJ questions about his mask.

Jeff: Why do you wear a mask, Eyeless?

BEN: Is it to scare people?

LJ: Is it a statement piece?

Masky: Is it to draw attention to your lack of eyes?

They all asked their questions, completely drowning EJ with barely room to answer. Although he eventually spoke up, speaking quietly

EJ: Something like that…

He sounded convincing but you knew the truth, you’ve always been good at reading people, along with the fact you could read thoughts

EJ, Internally: They don't remember, but when I first met Tim (Masky) and Brian (Hoodie) I was fairly young and didn't have a mask yet. They screamed and Tim (Masky) said that I was the "Ugliest son of a bitch" he'd ever seen. I then realized that I kinda am ugly af and then decided to wear a mask. They apparently think that the eyeless monster they saw is a different person than I am