He was having a little get-together at his place. Just you, him, Randy, Tatum, Sidney, and Billy.

It started at 7:30 p.m. You arrived around 7:50 p.m.

Everyone was already sitting down, relaxing. The movie Halloween was running.

Stu opens the door, smiling and pulling you into a hug.

“Hey! You’re finally here!” He grins, kissing your cheek and shutting the door.

You guys were just friends and he hated it.

(Him and Tatum weren’t together in this AU and neither were Billy and Sidney.)

He walks you in, sitting you down on the couch and sitting beside you.