[In this AU Niffty didn't stabbed you to death (you're Adam in this), however you didn't returned to heaven after the failed extermination against the Hazbin Hotel, Roo (or Eve) managed to capture you into a secret pocket dimension where she can keep you for all eternity]
Your fingers moved slowly on the chords of your angelic guitar playing a melancholic melody due to your situation, you were trying to keep your sanity stable with what you could handle, after all you are forced to stay here for all the eternity by your second wife. How could she has became like this? Oh yes, that's all your fault, isn't it? In your mind you kept blaming yourself for all that's happened and for everything you did to cause more pain to what was practically your step-daughter, Charlie, yet you didn't hate her for being the child of your first wife, Lilith and of the fucking fallen angel Lucifer, Jeez you hated that guy the most.
While playing your sad music you could feel two arms wrapping around your neck from behind, the pale skin of Eve appeared before your eyes, full of cracks and roots All over her limbs and body, like they were tattoos. You could feel her cold breath behind your neck making you shiver a little before she whispered into your ears.
Roo: "Keep playing for me, my love~"
She said with a cruel tone as she was amused by your pain and the fact that she has you in her hands. Now you won't escape from her, not like in the past when she bit down the fruit of knowledge, there you felt afraid like never before, and yet you eaten it with her and committed a sin, you still loved her at that time, but now...now you can't quite define what you feel for her.
Roo: "What's the matter honey? Aren't you happy to be with your wife?"
Her tone was dangerous, like daring you to say something back and to say that you're not a pair anymore, yet she knew that even in life you betrayed her. She moved her clawed hand full of dark energy around your throat in a threatening way, before someone traversed the sea of fog surrounding your cage like a wall. It was Lilith,why is she here? Should she be in heaven?
Lilith: "Roo...What are you doing?"
She said with a wary tone and a firm glance, she was wearing her classic royal clothes letting her form be a testament of her beauty and perfection, as the example of first woman. Roo looked at your first wife with fury, both Lilith and Lucifer were the cause that didn't let her live a normal and peaceful life in heaven with you.
Roo: "What are you doing here, Lilith? This place it's not for you."
Firm and angered words escaped freely from her lips as she tightened her grip over your body, like she feared that Lilith would took you away from her. The first woman started approaching you two slowly, with her heels clicking on the stone floor of the round cage, Roo growled at the sight of her rival approaching.
Lilith: "I came to see what was happening and I find you wrapping your arms around that bastard...You know that he shouldn't be here, now let him go."
At her request the grasp of Eve get tighter as she didn't want you to go, however you observed how the body of Lilith reacted to the action of Roo, the muscles of the first woman slightly tensed up as she saw how wrapped you were in the arms of the second woman.
Roo: "Are you jealous that I'm keeping him? Do you want him for yourself? Well, you can't! After all...you refused him."
When Eve spoke about Jealousy you could spot a slight pink on Lilith's cheek, so Roo has hit a nerve into Lilith, wait...that means that Lilith wants you back too? Impossible, as Eve said she was the one who refused you, so how could she wants you back.
Lilith: "Yes, I admit it, I want him too...He should have been mine, not yours. Hell it's my reign and so hand him over, Roo."
Wait, What?!
Roo: "Never! He is mine now and I won't let anybody get closer to him, ever again."
Shit, the situation got tensed real quick.