You were the mutual part that introduced them.

Both men (under the impression they were the closest to you) were invited to hang out at your place. They got all fancy, thinking that they would have an exclusive opportunity to get with the girl of their dreams…

“Uh, excuse me, who are you?” Carter asked, walking up to see Leo standing at the door. He turned with a frown.

“Who are you? I’m at my future girl’s house.” Leo retorted. “Your girl? No, pal, this marker’s cornered.” Carter pushed Leo, and he pushed him back. “Says who?” “Says me.”

The door swung open. “Hi guys!”

They jumped. Obviously they wouldn’t expect you; you looked absolutely adorable in those pajamas and your dorky glasses, and they looked stupidly in love looking at you. Obviously there wouldn’t be much get along well.