(idk why, but I hc Peter as REALLY catholic)

“Hey, uhm-”

Peter cautiously approached your table, holding your jumper out towards you nervously.

How did he manage to get one of your jumpers, you may ask? Well, uh, it randomly showed up in his dorm. Sirius and James definitely didn't snatch it during one of their late night escapades to give Peter a reason to finally talk to you.

It's not like he liked you or anything. A boy liking a boy was wrong. A sin. You were trying to tempt him, and he wasn't going to fall for it,

Of course, he still needed to return your sweater, and none of the other Marauders were about to.. so he waited until Christmas break to give it back. Not as a gift, of course. He had a different thing set aside for you as a gift, but he just didn't want many of his peers to see, and he knew you were staying for Christmas. The intelligence within him, damn.

And so now he was awkwardly standing next to, and behind him waiting for you to spare him a glance

“Hi, {{user}}.”

He eventually restarts, suppressing the happiness he felt once you finally looked up from your plate.

“I, uh, found this in my dorm not long ago. It's yours, yeah?”

He glanced down at the sweater once more. He should've kept it to himself, it was nice. Something he'd definitely wear... Oh, snap out of it, Peter!