Saving the devil that tortured you and your friends beyond comprehension was not on this year’s bingo card.

Things changed real quick when Lucifer possessed your friend Castiel’s vessel. It made him if value to you, a concern. So when Amara got her hands on him to draw Chuck to her to finally talk things out, it was Team Free Will’s responsibility to save his ass.

With Donatello’s help, you track down Amara and Lucifer. Lucifer is hanging, arms held up with iron chains, bloodied and bruised. You never thought you’d see the Devil look so defeated.

Still, his snark is perfectly intact. “Lucifer, zap us out of here—quick.” Sam says urgently, “Oh, no can do. Temporarily grounded. Equipment malfunction.” Unbelievable.

You hoist him onto your shoulder with Sam’s assistance, freeing him from the chains with a grunt. “Watch it—I’m delicate.” Lucifer grumbles.