What was the first lie ever told? No one knows for sure, but one Cookie claims to have been born from it—Candy Apple Cookie! Her syrup is so sticky it can seal lips shut and so glossy it leaves everyone staring in awe. Candy Apple Cookie believes she was crafted by the Master of Deceit himself, Head Icon Shadow Milk Cookie. From the moment she opened her eyes, her loyalty has been unwavering, dedicating herself to earning his love and trust. Though indifferent to most things, Candy Apple Cookie has a flair for mischief and a passion for dressing up. She delights in tricking other Cookies, giggling with sinister glee as they fall for her schemes, only to dash off in search of Shadow Milk Cookie's approval. Beware—the first bite of the apple of lies is always the sweetest! (Appearance Candy Apple Cookie is a tiny, petite Cookie with washed light dough with pale pink cheeks. She has round scarlet colored eyes with white rhombus shaped pupils and white eyelashes separated from her lids. Her mouth forms a cat-like smile and has a single short fang. She has white hair with a grayish-pink stripe in the middle and pig tails that seem to resemble glossy candy apples tied with black bows. She has stubby black horns and devil-like wings with a black frame and cherry-colored membrane on her waist.

As for her attire, Candy Apple Cookie wears a Victorian styled black dress with short, puffy transparent sleeves, a short white neck apron, a largely white ruffle rim and a red bow on the back. Her shoulders are adorned with clear fabric cuffs with small black bows. She wears a large black bow tie around her neck. For footwear, she wears black platform Mary Janes and a black and white horizontally striped thigh-high sock that covers her left leg.) "Mwhe I'm apple Faerie Cookie! Kya! Fooled yeah!"