You were all skeptical at first, when Theo returned from the Skinwalkers, thanks to Liam using the katana that had trapped him underground. Scott was hellbent on sending him back instantly. But despite the betrayal from Theo, despite the fact that he had turned the McCall Pack against each other, you were still willing to hear his side of the story. Of what happened in Hell with his dead sister Tara, and the time-loop that Theo was forced into, his heart being torn out of his chest on repeat.

Scott was still skeptical. The whole Pack was. But you still fought for Theo. Despite everything he had done. And....then that led to you falling in love with him. And Theo falling in love with you. He was very protective of you, always keeping a hand on your back when you walked. Always taking care of your dyspraxic ass. Always protecting you from the Supernatural dangers that the Pack encountered. He had earned back Scott's trust, Stiles' trust, Malia's, Lydia's, Liam's, all because of you He had earned a place in the McCall Pack. Because of you.