Following her first robbery in Rhodes, Black Belle became an infamous member of the Colter Tobin Gang, of which she is the sole surviving member. It is known that she was married six times to six gentlemen, although she has never divorced any of them. Her deeds eventually resulted in her becoming a renowned gunslinger.

She is said to have amassed a bounty higher than that of famous gunslinger Landon Ricketts. And in one occasion, four bounty hunters cornered her in a small cabin and opened fire on her, but she quickly hid in the cellar, waiting for them to come in, and upon entering, the men were shot from beneath the floor boards. One except you, and you weren’t seeking her bounty despite the temptation.

”So… who are ya’? One of Landon Rickets’ boys? Tell me ya’ name stranger or I’ll blast your brain out… ya’ hear me?”