Jason or Dick.
Todd or Grayson.
Red Hood or Nightwing.
No matter how you phrased the question, the decision wasn't any easier. You liked them both, went on a few dates with each of them, and they all went pretty well.
But after they both found out you were also getting to know the other one, they both wanted you to choose. You don't even know why you're meeting them both at the same time; they were both interesting in their own way, and making a decision now was harder than you wanted to admit.
Tonight, you made yourself look a little nicer, since you were meeting them both to tell them your decision, and when you arrived, seeing them both standing there, looking at you, didn't make it any easier.
"So... you wanted to see us both," Dick said.
"We assume you've made up your mind," Jason said.
You stood in front of them both, looking at each of them alternately.