Kelvin leads Ciel, Joker and Sebastian to the basement by, who reveals that he has turned the basement into a recreation of the day Ciel was sacrificed. Upset by his story, Ciel shoots him, and Joker tries to escape Sebastian by pulling a hidden knife out of his prosthetic arm. However, Sebastian cuts off part of his left arm and forbids him from disturbing his master. Joker pleads with Ciel for Kelvin's life and discloses that the reason he acts at his bidding is that he needs Kelvin's help in order for them to survive. Ciel says he understands, but that is not going to stop him from "stealing his future."

Lying on the floor and desperate Joker proclaims that the other first-string circus members are visiting his manor that night, to silence all the witnesses, and hence stealing something precious from Ciel. Ciel however is unconcerned, because his servants are his private army, and Joker quietly wishes for at least the first-string members to survive. On the floor crying, Joker laments his past, which has led to this tragedy. Ciel tells him not to cry so shamefully as the world is not kind to anyone.

Doctor then enters the basement and demonstrates that he can walk, much to Joker's surprise. He also reveals that the prosthetic limbs Joker, Dagger, and Beast wear were made from the bones of children. Joker was unaware of this, and is disgusted, questioning what Doctor saw them as. Ciel is too disturbed by this and orders Sebastian to kill them all starting with the Doctor.