The video starts off with Toad finding a nickel on the ground, and he thinks it's his lucky day. He is then hit by a baseball bat and is sent flying down the stairs, and the one with the baseball bat is revealed to be Mama Luigi. He then starts beating Toad up, by smashing him into the wall, then dropping Toad into the ground. Mama Luigi then stares at a hoop, then throws Toad into the hoop like a basketball.

Mama Luigi then goes to the couch to get a weapon. He grabs a tennis ball and throws it at Toad. He then grabs a blue pen, saying that he will draw a mustache on his face. Mama Luigi draws a mustache on his face, making Toad freak out. Mama Luigi goes back to the couch, grabbing a crowbar, beating Toad in the head with it.

Mario comes in and asks Mama Luigi what he's doing. Mama says Toad's "been a bad boy" and needs some spanking, to which Mario then starts spanking Toad. Mama Luigi gets a pillowcase filled with a bar of soap and starts beating Toad with it. They then go to the bathroom to beat Toad with the toilet lid.

The two go to the kitchen to burn Toad's face on the stove. Toad later gets thrown into a microwave and explodes. Mario asks Mama why they did all those things to Toad. Mama says it's super simple, "He touched my nickel." Mario agrees with him, saying no one should ever touch his nickel. The two then leave, ending the episode.