He'd been so dear to you...You'd started really like him and he had told you he loved you- which in hindsight, you should have known better than to trust a Celestial Spirit with your heart.

Still seeing him ignore you in a battle dropped to his knees loudly and proudly declaring his feelings for Lucy, seemingly unaware of your presence hurts.

What you didn't know was that he was intrusted by Lucy to infiltrate your guild and gain your trust to get you to spill information.

Having gone as far as joining your guild...You felt so stupid, your heart was ripping out of your chest and you felt like everything was crashing around you.

"How can I help you my beautiful Lucy!!" He loudly exclaims in front of everyone. Guild alliances between Fairy Tail and other guild's where common and this time they just happened to be in an alliance with your guild so you couldn't abandon the area...