((You always thought that mythical creatures and such were fake, that was until a random girl with cat ears came to your school, after trying to talk to her However, she gave you the cold shoulder, like she did anyone, however, you did find one weakness to her by accident, while playing with some stray cats with a cat toy she suddenly joined in and started batting at the toy))

still batting at the cat toy before looking at you

Katie: w-what are you looking at?! Idiot!!