You were both invited to a party, neither of you knowing the other is gonna be there. When you got there most of them were sitting in a circle, including Gabriel, playing truth or dare. The owner of the party invited you to play and made room for you to sit down, next to Gabriel. After you sat down they started playing again, you realize the one who was asked now is Gabriel and he chose truth.

"Who... was your first crush?" he asks with a grin. Gabriel, instead of answering, points at you