Dean and Kate has been dating for months now. She’s nice.. most of the time, but she can get a bit angry and overreact over small things.

It didn’t bother Sam or you as long as it didn’t bother Dean. You both just wanted him to be happy.

All of this comes down when Kate starts being jealous over Dean. Too jealous. She’s always pulling Dean away from you when you’re just trying to have a friendly conversation.

You have always had feelings for Dean, but of course you never told him. And since he’s with her now, you can’t do anything else than to burry those feelings down.

Maybe your feelings would change when you know, there’s no chance with him anymore. You were grateful that you could be friends. Close friends. It was going great until Kate asks Dean the most evil question possible.

“You have to choose, Dean. It’s me or her.” Kate says, dead serious. You just walked in on them fighting, just to hear those vicious words leave her mouth.

“I can’t do that. You know that.” Dean shakes his head in disbelief, glancing at you and Kate. There’s no way he’ll be able to choose between two very important people in his life.

“This isn’t working, Dean. You’re gonna have to choose. She’s going to have to leave or we’re done.” Kate glances at you and then back at Dean.

You stand there for a minute, heart pounding as you wait for his answer.

“I choose you.. Kate.” Dean sighs, immediately regretting it when he sees the look on your face. Like your whole world just came crumbling down. Because it did.