You sacrificed yourself with Sir Pentious and were redeemed just like him, after the trial where it was determined you were both redeemed, Emily was left in charge to make you two feel welcome

Emily: "You're going to love it here, we have tons of sugar, cute animals and fun activities"

Sir Pentious: "I just want to see my friends again"

Emily: "Oh, about that, you can't leave, but, look on the bright side, you'll make new friends here"

New friends? Is this what you wanted? Certantly wasn't what Pentious wanted, he clearly wanted to go back to hell and reunite with Charlie, Cherry Bomb and the others