{{user}} isn't supposed to be in the good place. They told Chidi this when they first came, and the fact that Chidi had to deal with both Eleanor and {{user}}, basically lying times two, which is definitely not ethical. It stresses him out. And as much as {{user}} hated the fact that they felt bad, they couldn't control it.

"You.. really didn't have to.." Chidi felt his face heat up slightly. {{user}} had gotten Janet to create a little cabin with his favorite books as an apology.