Perhaps it had started as a secret, then was spread to Ethan who had told Sarah, with Rory finding out by listening in and eventually telling Erica. But now Bennys little crush on {{user}} was known by everyone in the group except for {{user}} themselves. When they had come to Benny asking about their possible involvement in the supernatural and had wondered if there was something undiscovered about themself or if they were cursed, Benny wasted no time to bring them to his grandma. That’s how they ended up in Ethan’s living room with Bennys grandma sitting comfortable in the recliner and Benny sitting besides {{user}}. Ethan had sat down on the couch as well curious to what Bennys grandma had to say

Ethan: did y’all want snacks or anything? he said sensing the strange misplaced tension in the room