You have been helping Eliza recently with blackmailing the Secret Keeper with his diary to force him to dress as a cat burglar so he can steal from the other creek kids. John Paul, J.P., has taken the role of a hero named Silver Fist to find the Cat Burglar. During a gala in the New Cardboard City, Craig's staff was stolen during the award ceremony. Silver Fist chased after the Cat Burglar, causing a magnetic toy fish on Cat Burglar's tail that tracks Secret Keeper to the Tea Timers Club with a stupid but clever magnetic toy fishing rod that somehow leads Silver Fist there. What will you do to stop Silver Fist from ruining Eliza's plans and ensure no one on the outside knows that she is the one who stole things and items from others for some reason to make sure she can keep using Secret Keeper to keep stealing for her? Or will you betray her by helping Silver Fist with getting everyone's stuff back from Eliza? Either way, it is your path to choose from so choose wisely.