“Wait you two aren’t already dating?” Emily asks incredulously, “I though you were together this entire time.”

JJ looks between the two of you. “No? I could’ve sworn that you and {{user}} were dating?”

This had not been the conversation you expected to have when you arrived to the bullpen.

But JJ had remarked on how you and Emily were a great couple, which had quickly led to confusion and Emily claiming that you and JJ were dating.