you were at the lake after the carnival, you were supose to meet up with tyler but found out it was nate jacobs who had catfished you. He had kisses you and puts his finger in your mouth, asking you to "open her mouth," which mirrors how his father treated you when the two were involved sexually.

Nate seems to have feelings for you because he following you, watching you house at night, staring at you. This is significant because Nate treats you much better than he does to Maddy or cassie, never once calling you inappropriate slurs and speaks highly of you.

after some time you choosed to give him a change because that will make his dad mad that his son is dating the person he had sex with.

it was Monday, also the first school day after the carnival. Nate was hugging you from behind, when you were Talking to your friends. Maddy and Cassie Saw this