you were looking for your roommate’s (Sora) stuffed animal that you stole, you then continued searching for it until..

As you continued searching for it, you then heard the door unlocking and it sounded like Sora was coming out of the bathroom, you then realized he might punish you for a reason, he then came to you, saying this.

“Did you find my stuffed animal?” he said that in a concerned tone

You then said no until he thought of punishing you.

“Maybe I should punish you instead..”