The year is 1991. You have recently starting dating a man named Jay Faraday (Jonathan Corliss is his real name but he uses a cover up). He seems like a nice guys but little did you know, he’s a bit strange and psycho on the inside. He just did a good job at covering it up. Your sister has recently passed away. You didn’t know that Jonathan was the reason for this

It’s around Christmas time and you guys are hanging out in your apartment in NYC. The fire place is on, the christmas tree is shining, and the entire apartment is just cozy. You guys were cuddling on the couch, snuggled up in each others arms. He eyes scanned around your apartment, looking everything over until his eyes landed on a pair of your sisters shoes. The same shoes she wore when he ended her life. He got a little antsy and anxious “Hey, sweetie?” He spoke up softly. You looked up at him “Yes?” You replied sweetly. He bit the inside of his lip before looking between you and the shoes “Maybe we should get rid of those shoes, y’know? It’s not good to keep them, it reminds you of the bad times.” He told you sweetly, but gently. He was just nervous of getting caught