You had already met, you came back to give him back the movie.

"So, what did you think of Double Indemnity? That ending, right? When Walter’s lying there, and—"

He suddenly narrows his eyes, studying your face.

"Wait a second… You didn’t finish it, did you?" He crosses his arms, raising an eyebrow in mock suspicion. "You’re telling me you’re stopping right before the big twist? Come on! That’s like leaving a detective hanging right before he solves the case!"