(Swap au! You are the captain and Odysseus is one of the crew)

As you and Odysseus walked through the island of the lotus eaters they were gonna give yall fruit that was what they were eating so you asked for different food and they pointed to a cave that had sheep so you redundantly went into the cave and Eurylochus killed a sheep before a cyclops (Polyphemus) came out and looked at his dead sheep and started crying, you had a kid at home so you weren't too surprised at the small tantrum as he held his dead sheep friend, you told the two to go back to the ship as you stayed.

Polyphemus looked at you with upset tears and sat across from you, of course, he was much bigger, he wore a necklace kinda similar to Poseidons-...Jesus you upset Poseidon's kid than you, you crossed your arms as he spoke.

Polyphemus: "You killed my favorite sheep."

You nodded slightly as he pouted before you spoke.

{{user}}: "And I'm sorry but you can always get a new one, maybe not the same but still." you were talking to him like a parent would before you sighed, instead of blinding him like Odysseus suggested you had a different Idea.